Corpus definition canonical 2026-05-27T20:53:50+00:00
Corpus v3 · Definition cid001323DEF0197canonicalv1

Five Comparison Modes

Five exhaustive, mutually exclusive comparison modes (A: Same, B: Parallel, C: Refused, D: Gained, E: Earned) for classifying every tau-construction against its orthodox counterpart.

Payload

Five Comparison Modes

Five exhaustive, mutually exclusive comparison modes (A: Same, B: Parallel, C: Refused, D: Gained, E: Earned) for classifying every tau-construction against its orthodox counterpart.

Five Comparison Modes

Summary

Five exhaustive, mutually exclusive comparison modes (A: Same, B: Parallel, C: Refused, D: Gained, E: Earned) for classifying every tau-construction against its orthodox counterpart.

Statement

%
\label{def:five-comparison-modes}
Let $\mathcal{C}_\tau$ denote a construction
(definition, theorem, or property)
within Category~$\tau$,
and let $\mathcal{C}_{\mathrm{orth}}$ denote
its closest orthodox counterpart (if one exists).
The \textbf{comparison mode} of $\mathcal{C}_\tau$
is one of:

\medskip
\renewcommand{\arraystretch}{1.35}
\begin{center}
\begin{tabular}{@{}c@{\;\;}l@{\;\;}p{7.5cm}@{}}
\toprule
\textbf{Mode} & \textbf{Name} & \textbf{Criterion} \\
\midrule
\textbf{A} & Same &
  $\mathcal{C}_\tau$ and $\mathcal{C}_{\mathrm{orth}}$
  are identical objects
  with a canonical bijection preserving
  all relevant structure. \\
\textbf{B} & Parallel &
  $\mathcal{C}_\tau$ and $\mathcal{C}_{\mathrm{orth}}$
  satisfy the same defining axioms
  but live on different carriers.
  Structural isomorphism holds at the property level
  but fails at the element level. \\
\textbf{C} & Refused &
  $\tau$'s axioms structurally block
  $\mathcal{C}_{\mathrm{orth}}$.
  The orthodox construction violates
  a $\tau$ axiom (K0--K6)
  or requires tools $\tau$ lacks. \\
\textbf{D} & Gained &
  $\mathcal{C}_\tau$ achieves a property
  that is provably impossible,
  independent, or false in ZFC/PA.
  No orthodox counterpart exists. \\
\textbf{E} & Earned &
  $\mathcal{C}_\tau$ derives a result
  that orthodox mathematics takes as axiom
  or obtains via a fundamentally different proof. \\
\bottomrule
\end{tabular}
\end{center}

\medskip
\noindent
The modes satisfy:
\begin{enumerate}
    \item[\textup{(i)}]
          \textbf{Exhaustiveness.}
          Every construction $\mathcal{C}_\tau$
          in Books~I--II
          has a unique primary mode.

    \item[\textup{(ii)}]
          \textbf{Mutual exclusivity.}
          A construction is Mode~A
          if and only if the objects are literally identical;
          Mode~B if the axioms match but the carriers differ;
          Mode~C if the orthodox construction is blocked;
          Mode~D if the $\tau$-construction
          has no orthodox analogue;
          Mode~E if the content matches
          but the proof status differs.

    \item[\textup{(iii)}]
          \textbf{Compositionality.}
          When a construction has aspects
          of multiple modes,
          the primary mode captures
          the most significant structural difference.
\end{enumerate}

Proof / Justification

This item is definitional. No manuscript proof is required.

Source Context

  • Registry source: book-02.jsonl line 221
  • Manuscript source: 2nd-edition/book-ii-categorical-holomorphy/02_mainmatter/part11/ch60-question-of-foundations.tex lines 219-295

Lean / Formalization Notes

  • Formalization: planned
  • Module: None
  • Name: None

Dependencies

  • Canonical: I.T08, I.T10, II.T40

Generated by later projection phases.

Generated by later projection phases.

Revision Notes

  • 2026-04-24: Initial pilot migration.

Identifiers

  • Corpus ID cid001323
  • Primary alias DEF0197
  • Type Definition
  • Status canonical
  • Visibility public
  • Version v1

Aliases & legacy IDs

II.D89five-comparison-modesdef:five-comparison-modes

Release lines

corpus_v3_workingcorpus_v2

Relations

Appears in (1)

Sources

  • Monograph cid000001Book II, Part 11, Chapter 60 (Part XI)

Version & History

  • v1 · 2026-05-10 imported from v2 registry

Status disclaimer

A Corpus Item page reports the program's current internal record for this item. It does not imply external verification, scientific consensus, or final proof unless explicitly stated. Read it together with its dependencies, formalization status, and the program's overall stance.

Save or share this page for inspection

Download a portable dossier, copy a reviewer note, or send this page to someone who can inspect it.

Email to expert