Causation (constrained composition)
Causation, in the τ-framework, is admissible factorization of morphisms in the coherence kernel. f causes g iff g decomposes as h ∘ f for some admissible h that respects the kernel's narrowing rules. Causation is therefore structural and categorical — not a Humean regularity, not a brute productive relation, not a counterfactual primitive.
τ-Definition
Causation, in the τ-framework, is admissible factorization of morphisms in the coherence kernel. f causes g iff g decomposes as h ∘ f for some admissible h that respects the kernel's narrowing rules. Causation is therefore structural and categorical — not a Humean regularity, not a brute productive relation, not a counterfactual primitive.
Categorical invariant. f →_c g ⟺ ∃ h ∈ AdmMor(K_τ) : g = h ∘ f ∧ h satisfies OR1–OR6.
Primary registry anchor:
VII.D32
τ-Derivation Chain
-
VII.D37— Six Ontic Requirements (OR1–OR6) — admissibility constraints on kernel morphisms. -
VII.D31— Law as admissible continuation — laws are the admissibility class for kernel morphisms. -
VII.D32— Causation as Constrained Composition — f causes g iff g admissibly factors through f. -
VII.P06— Temporal ordering from persistence — causal asymmetry inherits from the persistence-induced temporal order.
Lean modules referenced:
TauLib.BookVII.Meta.Registers
Phenomenological Correlate
Causation is instantiated whenever we say 'A brings about B', 'A produces B', or 'A is the reason B happened'. Striking a match causes flame; passing a law causes legal-state-change; proving a lemma causes the dependent theorem to follow; committing to a course causes downstream stance-change. All four are read as admissible factorizations in the relevant register's morphism class.
Examples:
- Empirical: 'striking the match caused the flame' — flame-state morphism factors admissibly through strike-state morphism.
- Normative: 'enacting the law caused the legal-state change' — legal-update morphism factors admissibly through enactment morphism in Reg_P.
- Proof-theoretic: 'the lemma caused the theorem to follow' — theorem-derivation factors admissibly through the lemma-derivation in Reg_D.
- Commitment-theoretic: 'the promise caused the obligation' — obligation-stance factors admissibly through promise-stance in Reg_C.
Register codomain: Cross-register (causation is defined wherever a register has admissible morphisms; the structure is uniform).
Manuscript reference: manuscript-sources/book-07/part02/ch24.tex
Lean Coverage
Status: Formalized
Module: TauLib.BookVII.Meta.Registers
Lean kind: def
Lean symbol: Tau.BookVII.Meta.Registers.CausationAsConstrainedComposition