LEM0008canonicalv1Tail Agreement Propagation
If two tower-coherent stagewise functions agree at stage d0 for all inputs, they agree at ALL stages k <= d0. The downward direction: agreement at a fine stage implies agreement at all coarser stages.
Payload
Tail Agreement Propagation
If two tower-coherent stagewise functions agree at stage d0 for all inputs, they agree at ALL stages k <= d0. The downward direction: agreement at a fine stage implies agreement at all coarser stages.
Tail Agreement Propagation
Summary
If two tower-coherent stagewise functions agree at stage d0 for all inputs, they agree at ALL stages k <= d0. The downward direction: agreement at a fine stage implies agreement at all coarser stages.
Statement
%
\label{lem:tail-agreement-propagation}
Let $T, S \in \mathrm{HolFun}$.
If $T$ and $S$ agree at depth $d_0$
(Definition~\ref{def:tail-agreement}),
then they agree at \emph{all} depths.
That is:
\[
\boxed{%
T \sim_{d_0} S
\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;
\forall\, d \geq 1,\;
\forall\, t \text{ with } \mathrm{depth}(t) \geq d,\;
\forall\, k \leq d:\;
\bigl(T(t)\bigr)_k = \bigl(S(t)\bigr)_k.}
\]
Proof / Justification
By induction on $d$, starting from $d_0$.
\textbf{Base case} ($d = d_0$):
this is the hypothesis $T \sim_{d_0} S$.
\textbf{Induction step} ($d \to d + 1$):
assume $T$ and $S$ agree at depth $d$.
We show they agree at depth $d + 1$.
Take any omega-tail $t$ of depth $\geq d + 1$.
At primorial stage $M_{d+1} = M_d \cdot p_{d+1}$,
the Chinese Remainder Theorem gives the decomposition:
\[
\mathbb{Z}/M_{d+1}\mathbb{Z}
\;\cong\;
\mathbb{Z}/M_d\mathbb{Z}
\;\times\;
\mathbb{Z}/p_{d+1}\mathbb{Z}.
\]
By the induction hypothesis,
$T(t)$ and $S(t)$ agree on the
$\mathbb{Z}/M_d\mathbb{Z}$ factor:
for all $k \leq d$,
$\bigl(T(t)\bigr)_k = \bigl(S(t)\bigr)_k$.
It remains to show agreement
on the $\mathbb{Z}/p_{d+1}\mathbb{Z}$ factor.
Tower coherence
(Definition~\ref{def:tower-coherence}, I.D46)
gives:
\[
T(t) \bmod M_d \;=\; T(t \bmod M_d),
\qquad
S(t) \bmod M_d \;=\; S(t \bmod M_d).
\]
The reduction $t \bmod M_d$
is an omega-tail of depth $d$.
By the induction hypothesis,
$T(t \bmod M_d) = S(t \bmod M_d)$
at all components $k \leq d$.
Now the CRT coherence constraint
(Theorem~\ref{thm:crt-coherence}, I.T18)
enters.
A HolFun's action on $\mathbb{Z}/M_{d+1}\mathbb{Z}$
is determined by its actions on the two CRT factors
$\mathbb{Z}/M_d\mathbb{Z}$ and $\mathbb{Z}/p_{d+1}\mathbb{Z}$.
The CRT coherence condition requires
that the $p_{d+1}$-factor of the output
is consistent with the already-determined lower stages:
the action on $\mathbb{Z}/p_{d+1}\mathbb{Z}$
is constrained by the requirement
that the full CRT reconstruction
at stage $M_{d+1}$
must be compatible with the tower reduction
to stage $M_d$.
Since $T$ and $S$ agree on the $\mathbb{Z}/M_d\mathbb{Z}$ factor,
and both satisfy CRT coherence,
the $p_{d+1}$-factor of $T(t)$ and $S(t)$
must agree as well ---
because any discrepancy on the $p_{d+1}$-factor
would violate the CRT coherence constraint
for the tower reduction
$M_{d+1} \to M_d$.
Therefore $\bigl(T(t)\bigr)_{d+1} = \bigl(S(t)\bigr)_{d+1}$,
completing the induction.
Source Context
- Registry source:
book-01.jsonlline 119 - Manuscript source:
2nd-edition/book-i-categorical-foundations/02_mainmatter/part13/ch52-identity-theorem.texlines 195-212
Lean / Formalization Notes
- Formalization:
formalized - Module:
TauLib.BookI.Holomorphy.IdentityTheorem - Name:
Tau.Holomorphy.tail_agree_propagation
Dependencies
- Canonical: I.D46
Related Results
Generated by later projection phases.
Related Publications
Generated by later projection phases.
Revision Notes
- 2026-04-24: Initial pilot migration.
Identifiers
Aliases & legacy IDs
I.L07tail-agreement-propagationlem:tail-agreement-propagationRelease lines
corpus_v3_workingcorpus_v2Relations
Formalized by (1)
Appears in (1)
Downstream uses (computed) (2)
Items in the corpus that reference this one via load-bearing relations. Computed from the full corpus-v3 graph at build time.
Sources
Version & History
Status disclaimer
A Corpus Item page reports the program's current internal record for this item. It does not imply external verification, scientific consensus, or final proof unless explicitly stated. Read it together with its dependencies, formalization status, and the program's overall stance.