DEF0089canonicalv1Enrichment Frontier Classification
Three statuses: achieved (E0-E1), partially achieved (E1-E2), unprecedented (E2-E3).
Payload
Enrichment Frontier Classification
Three statuses: achieved (E0-E1), partially achieved (E1-E2), unprecedented (E2-E3).
Enrichment Frontier Classification
Summary
Three statuses: achieved (E0-E1), partially achieved (E1-E2), unprecedented (E2-E3).
Statement
%
\label{def:enrichment-frontier}
The \textbf{enrichment frontier classification}
assigns a novelty status to each transition
of the enrichment ladder:
\begin{enumerate}
\item \textbf{$E_0 \to E_1$: Achieved.}
Internalizing types within a categorical framework
has been accomplished by multiple groups
(Altenkirch--Kaposi \cite{AltenkirchKaposi2016},
Bocquet--Kaposi--Sattler \cite{BocquetKaposiSattler2023},
Moerdijk--Palmgren \cite{MoerdijkPalmgren2002}).
Adaptation to $\tau$'s finite constructive
non-Boolean setting is required but is not
a theoretical barrier.
\item \textbf{$E_1 \to E_2$: Partially achieved.}
Internal proof-theoretic reasoning exists
(Joyal arithmetic universes
\cite{vanDijkGietelinkOldenziel2020}).
Resource-sensitive type theory exists
(graded modal DTT \cite{Abel2023},
substructural DTT \cite{SubstructuralDTT2024}).
The combination into a complete system
internalizing full linear proof theory
within a categorical framework
has not been accomplished.
Novel assembly of known tools.
\item \textbf{$E_2 \to E_3$: Unprecedented.}
No formal system of meaningful mathematical strength
achieves full self-hosting.
Willard \cite{Willard2001}: self-verification
at sub-PA strength.
Girard \cite{Girard2016TS,Eng2023}:
fragments of linear logic from sub-logical operations.
Williams--Stay \cite{WilliamsStay2021}:
native $*$-autonomous type theory (programmatic).
An open research problem.
\end{enumerate}
Proof / Justification
This item is definitional. No manuscript proof is required.
Source Context
- Registry source:
book-01.jsonlline 181 - Manuscript source:
2nd-edition/book-i-categorical-foundations/02_mainmatter/part18/ch73-enrichment-frontier.texlines 543-582
Lean / Formalization Notes
- Formalization:
formalized - Module:
TauLib.BookI.MetaLogic.StructuralExclusion - Name:
EnrichmentFrontierStatus
Dependencies
- Canonical: I.D80, I.T39
Related Results
Generated by later projection phases.
Related Publications
Generated by later projection phases.
Revision Notes
- 2026-04-24: Initial pilot migration.
Identifiers
Aliases & legacy IDs
I.D82enrichment-frontier-classificationdef:enrichment-frontierRelease lines
corpus_v3_workingcorpus_v2Relations
Appears in (1)
Sources
Version & History
Status disclaimer
A Corpus Item page reports the program's current internal record for this item. It does not imply external verification, scientific consensus, or final proof unless explicitly stated. Read it together with its dependencies, formalization status, and the program's overall stance.